Strictly viewers may force format change after criticism of new presenters

BBC producers are facing an immediate backlash from Strictly Come Dancing viewers over the show’s new presenting lineup, forcing showrunners to consider a last-minute shake-up ahead of next week’s first live show.

Strictly fans overwhelmed by three presenter format

• Viewer Backlash: Audiences have taken to social media to voice frustration over the new three-way hosting dynamic, threatening to derail the producers’ vision of an “equal partnership.”
• Production Pivot: Execs are now reportedly considering assigning fixed, designated roles to the trio—echoing the classic format used by Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman—rather than letting them split duties evenly.
• Standout Host: Emma Willis has earned widespread acclaim for her professional, polished delivery, leaning heavily on her extensive live broadcasting experience from Big Brother.
• Host Under Fire: While dancer Johannes Radebe has received warm support as he settles into the role, comedian Josh Widdicombe has faced harsh criticism, with viewers labeling his performance “wooden,” “awkward,” and “out of his depth.”

The mounting criticism directly undermines what the new hosting team had previously declared about their setup, having insisted that all three presenters would operate as equals and share the workload seamlessly. However, fans watching the pre-recorded launch sequence felt the triple-host experiment made the staging cluttered and unbalanced.

With the high-stakes first live broadcast scheduled for next week, the trio will be put to the ultimate test under live conditions. While Emma Willis remains a safe, seasoned pair of hands to anchor the chaos, the heat is firmly on production to refine the dynamic before camera rolling.

Social media reaction was swift and uncompromising following the broadcast:

RosemaryKnight @RSK176 · 3m Emma is doing a grand job — looks good and so professional — johannes looks great always and fabulous dancer but not comfortable in new role as yet but will relax into it I’m sure —- Josh just shouldn’t be there, dreadful choice! #Strictly #Strictlycomedancing

Jackie Johnson @JackieJ94674763 · 4m #Strictly for the first time ever I’ve switched to a different channel, Emma and JoJo are good, Josh and the rest of the program are boring

My lovely horse @SueJ1973 · 17m Josh seems a bit surplus to requirements. Emma & Jojo are great though #Strictly

Other fans were more sympathetic and said the new trio simply needs more time to settle in.

The first live show is next Saturday night, with the first results show in two weeks time.

Share this post with someone you think would like it: